"Intelligent design" scam loses big-time in federal court
Judge John E. Jones III of the Pennsylvania federal district court hearing the Kitzmiller vs Dover Area School District, challenge to the required teaching, a challege to the required teaching of "intelligent design" (ID) as science, has handed down his ruling. And he came down hard on the Christian Right scamsters.
His opinion is available online: Memorandum Opinion 12/20/05, US District Court for the Middle District of Pennsylvania. The court's bottom-line ruling:
For the reasons that follow, we hold that the ID Policy is unconstitutional pursuant to the Establishment Clause of the First Amendment of the United States Constitution and Art. I, § 3 of the Pennsylvania Constitution. What's valuable about this opinion is that Judge Jones, a Republican appointed by George W. Bush, lays out his reasoning in some detail for finding that ID is a "religious" claim, not science.
One sample from Jones' opinion: The concept of intelligent design (hereinafter "ID"), in its current form, came into existence after the Edwards case was decided in 1987. For the reasons that follow, we conclude that the religious nature of ID would be readily apparent to an objective observer, adult or child . We initially note that John Haught, a theologian who testified as an expert witness for Plaintiffs and who has written extensively on the subject of evolution and religion, succinctly explained to the Court that the argument for ID is not a new scientific argument, but is rather an old religious argument for the existence of God . He traced this argument back to at least Thomas Aquinas in the 13th century, who framed the argument as a syllogism: Wherever complex design exists, there must have been a designer; nature is complex; therefore nature must have had an intelligent designer. (Trial Tr. vol. 9, Haught Test., 7-8, Sept. 30, 2005). Dr. Haught testified that Aquinas was explicit that this intelligent designer "everyone understands to be God." Id. The syllogism described by Dr. Haught is essentially the same argument for ID as presented by defense expert witnesses Professors Behe and Minnich who employ the phrase "purposeful arrangement of parts." (my emphasis) The decision is getting wide news coverage:Federal judge rules against intelligent design in science classrooms: Dover, Pa., school board requirement unconstitutional, 'sham,' judge says by Tracie Mauriello Pittsburgh Post-Gazette 12/21/05Intelligent design is struck down: A judge ruled it a "relabeling of creationism" and said it had no place in a 9th-grade science class by Amy Worden Philadelphia Inquirer 12/21/05Intelligent design loses: Pa. judge rejects concept; next challenge could target Ohio plan by Scott Stephens Cleveland Plain Dealer 12/21/05.Intelligent design ruled religion, not scientific theory Judge rules against intelligent design by Mike Weiss San Francisco Chronicle 12/21/05Darwin's descendant likes how the 'intelligent design' case evolved by Tracie Mauriello Pittsburgh Post-Gazette 12/21/05 (Ouch! at the headline writer's sense of humor)Judge Says 'Intelligent Design' Is Not Science: He calls a school board's effort to teach it as an alternative to evolution unconstitutional by Henry Weinstein Los Angeles Times 12/21/05US judge rejects intelligent design: Broad ruling finds Pa. school board promoted religion by Nina Easton Boston Globe 12/21/05US judge rejects intelligent design by Jill Lawrence USA Today 12/21/05A federal judge ruled Tuesday that "Intelligent Design" cannot be mentioned during classes in a Pennsylvania school district, bringing to a close the most significant trial involving evolution in nearly 20 years Christian Post (a fundamentalist source) 12/20/05Federal judge rules against Intelligent Design theory by James Patterson [Southern] Baptist Press 12/20/05 I hope someone from our "press corps" asks Maverick McCain and President Bush, both of whom have endorsed teaching the ID hustle as science, to give their responses to Judge Jones' ruling.
|
+Save/Share
|
|
FEATURED QUOTE
"It is the logic of our times No subject for immortal verse That we who lived by honest dreams Defend the bad against the worse."
-- Cecil Day-Lewis from Where Are The War Poets?
ABOUT US
What is the Blue Voice?
Bruce Miller
Fdtate
Marcia Ellen (on hiatus)
Marigolds2
Neil
Tankwoman
Wonky Muse
RECENT POSTS
Carnival of The Green 7
George Bush is a Liar
Carnival of The Liberals
The Christian Right on why Jesus wants Christians ...
'Tis the season - for bad archaeology and sloppy h...
Reading the News Is Bad for My Mental Health
The Big Irony
The Fear Cancer
Did the Terri Schiavo hoopla bring "blowback" agai...
The Christian Right, the South and the Christian R...
ARCHIVES
Weekly, Click Here >>>
06/12/2005 - 06/19/2005
06/19/2005 - 06/26/2005
06/26/2005 - 07/03/2005
07/03/2005 - 07/10/2005
07/10/2005 - 07/17/2005
07/17/2005 - 07/24/2005
07/24/2005 - 07/31/2005
07/31/2005 - 08/07/2005
08/07/2005 - 08/14/2005
08/14/2005 - 08/21/2005
08/21/2005 - 08/28/2005
08/28/2005 - 09/04/2005
09/04/2005 - 09/11/2005
09/11/2005 - 09/18/2005
09/18/2005 - 09/25/2005
09/25/2005 - 10/02/2005
10/02/2005 - 10/09/2005
10/09/2005 - 10/16/2005
10/16/2005 - 10/23/2005
10/23/2005 - 10/30/2005
10/30/2005 - 11/06/2005
11/06/2005 - 11/13/2005
11/13/2005 - 11/20/2005
11/20/2005 - 11/27/2005
11/27/2005 - 12/04/2005
12/04/2005 - 12/11/2005
12/11/2005 - 12/18/2005
12/18/2005 - 12/25/2005
12/25/2005 - 01/01/2006
01/01/2006 - 01/08/2006
01/08/2006 - 01/15/2006
01/15/2006 - 01/22/2006
01/22/2006 - 01/29/2006
01/29/2006 - 02/05/2006
02/05/2006 - 02/12/2006
02/12/2006 - 02/19/2006
02/19/2006 - 02/26/2006
02/26/2006 - 03/05/2006
03/05/2006 - 03/12/2006
03/12/2006 - 03/19/2006
03/19/2006 - 03/26/2006
03/26/2006 - 04/02/2006
04/02/2006 - 04/09/2006
04/09/2006 - 04/16/2006
04/16/2006 - 04/23/2006
04/23/2006 - 04/30/2006
04/30/2006 - 05/07/2006
05/07/2006 - 05/14/2006
05/14/2006 - 05/21/2006
05/21/2006 - 05/28/2006
05/28/2006 - 06/04/2006
06/04/2006 - 06/11/2006
06/11/2006 - 06/18/2006
06/18/2006 - 06/25/2006
06/25/2006 - 07/02/2006
07/02/2006 - 07/09/2006
07/09/2006 - 07/16/2006
07/16/2006 - 07/23/2006
07/23/2006 - 07/30/2006
07/30/2006 - 08/06/2006
08/06/2006 - 08/13/2006
08/13/2006 - 08/20/2006
08/20/2006 - 08/27/2006
08/27/2006 - 09/03/2006
09/03/2006 - 09/10/2006
09/10/2006 - 09/17/2006
09/17/2006 - 09/24/2006
09/24/2006 - 10/01/2006
10/01/2006 - 10/08/2006
10/08/2006 - 10/15/2006
10/15/2006 - 10/22/2006
10/22/2006 - 10/29/2006
10/29/2006 - 11/05/2006
11/05/2006 - 11/12/2006
11/12/2006 - 11/19/2006
11/19/2006 - 11/26/2006
11/26/2006 - 12/03/2006
12/03/2006 - 12/10/2006
12/10/2006 - 12/17/2006
12/17/2006 - 12/24/2006
12/24/2006 - 12/31/2006
12/31/2006 - 01/07/2007
01/07/2007 - 01/14/2007
01/14/2007 - 01/21/2007
01/21/2007 - 01/28/2007
01/28/2007 - 02/04/2007
02/04/2007 - 02/11/2007
02/11/2007 - 02/18/2007
02/18/2007 - 02/25/2007
02/25/2007 - 03/04/2007
03/04/2007 - 03/11/2007
03/11/2007 - 03/18/2007
03/18/2007 - 03/25/2007
03/25/2007 - 04/01/2007
04/01/2007 - 04/08/2007
04/08/2007 - 04/15/2007
04/15/2007 - 04/22/2007
04/22/2007 - 04/29/2007
04/29/2007 - 05/06/2007
05/06/2007 - 05/13/2007
05/13/2007 - 05/20/2007
05/20/2007 - 05/27/2007
05/27/2007 - 06/03/2007
06/03/2007 - 06/10/2007
06/10/2007 - 06/17/2007
06/17/2007 - 06/24/2007
06/24/2007 - 07/01/2007
07/01/2007 - 07/08/2007
07/08/2007 - 07/15/2007
07/15/2007 - 07/22/2007
07/22/2007 - 07/29/2007
07/29/2007 - 08/05/2007
08/05/2007 - 08/12/2007
08/12/2007 - 08/19/2007
08/19/2007 - 08/26/2007
08/26/2007 - 09/02/2007
09/02/2007 - 09/09/2007
09/09/2007 - 09/16/2007
09/16/2007 - 09/23/2007
09/23/2007 - 09/30/2007
09/30/2007 - 10/07/2007
10/07/2007 - 10/14/2007
10/14/2007 - 10/21/2007
10/21/2007 - 10/28/2007
10/28/2007 - 11/04/2007
11/04/2007 - 11/11/2007
11/11/2007 - 11/18/2007
11/18/2007 - 11/25/2007
11/25/2007 - 12/02/2007
12/02/2007 - 12/09/2007
12/09/2007 - 12/16/2007
12/16/2007 - 12/23/2007
12/23/2007 - 12/30/2007
12/30/2007 - 01/06/2008
01/06/2008 - 01/13/2008
01/13/2008 - 01/20/2008
01/20/2008 - 01/27/2008
01/27/2008 - 02/03/2008
02/03/2008 - 02/10/2008
02/10/2008 - 02/17/2008
02/17/2008 - 02/24/2008
02/24/2008 - 03/02/2008
03/02/2008 - 03/09/2008
03/09/2008 - 03/16/2008
03/16/2008 - 03/23/2008
03/23/2008 - 03/30/2008
03/30/2008 - 04/06/2008
04/06/2008 - 04/13/2008
04/13/2008 - 04/20/2008
04/20/2008 - 04/27/2008
04/27/2008 - 05/04/2008
05/04/2008 - 05/11/2008
05/11/2008 - 05/18/2008
05/18/2008 - 05/25/2008
05/25/2008 - 06/01/2008
06/01/2008 - 06/08/2008
06/08/2008 - 06/15/2008
06/15/2008 - 06/22/2008
06/22/2008 - 06/29/2008
06/29/2008 - 07/06/2008
07/06/2008 - 07/13/2008
07/13/2008 - 07/20/2008
07/20/2008 - 07/27/2008
07/27/2008 - 08/03/2008
08/03/2008 - 08/10/2008
08/10/2008 - 08/17/2008
08/17/2008 - 08/24/2008
08/24/2008 - 08/31/2008
08/31/2008 - 09/07/2008
09/07/2008 - 09/14/2008
09/14/2008 - 09/21/2008
09/21/2008 - 09/28/2008
09/28/2008 - 10/05/2008
10/05/2008 - 10/12/2008
10/12/2008 - 10/19/2008
10/19/2008 - 10/26/2008
10/26/2008 - 11/02/2008
11/02/2008 - 11/09/2008
11/09/2008 - 11/16/2008
11/16/2008 - 11/23/2008
11/23/2008 - 11/30/2008
11/30/2008 - 12/07/2008
12/07/2008 - 12/14/2008
12/14/2008 - 12/21/2008
12/21/2008 - 12/28/2008
12/28/2008 - 01/04/2009
01/04/2009 - 01/11/2009
01/11/2009 - 01/18/2009
01/18/2009 - 01/25/2009
01/25/2009 - 02/01/2009
02/01/2009 - 02/08/2009
02/08/2009 - 02/15/2009
02/15/2009 - 02/22/2009
02/22/2009 - 03/01/2009
03/01/2009 - 03/08/2009
03/08/2009 - 03/15/2009
03/15/2009 - 03/22/2009
03/22/2009 - 03/29/2009
03/29/2009 - 04/05/2009
04/05/2009 - 04/12/2009
04/12/2009 - 04/19/2009
04/19/2009 - 04/26/2009
04/26/2009 - 05/03/2009
05/03/2009 - 05/10/2009
05/10/2009 - 05/17/2009
05/17/2009 - 05/24/2009
05/24/2009 - 05/31/2009
05/31/2009 - 06/07/2009
06/07/2009 - 06/14/2009
06/14/2009 - 06/21/2009
06/21/2009 - 06/28/2009
06/28/2009 - 07/05/2009
07/05/2009 - 07/12/2009
07/12/2009 - 07/19/2009
07/19/2009 - 07/26/2009
07/26/2009 - 08/02/2009
08/02/2009 - 08/09/2009
08/09/2009 - 08/16/2009
08/16/2009 - 08/23/2009
08/23/2009 - 08/30/2009
08/30/2009 - 09/06/2009
09/06/2009 - 09/13/2009
09/13/2009 - 09/20/2009
09/20/2009 - 09/27/2009
09/27/2009 - 10/04/2009
10/04/2009 - 10/11/2009
10/11/2009 - 10/18/2009
10/18/2009 - 10/25/2009
10/25/2009 - 11/01/2009
11/01/2009 - 11/08/2009
11/08/2009 - 11/15/2009
11/15/2009 - 11/22/2009
11/22/2009 - 11/29/2009
11/29/2009 - 12/06/2009
12/06/2009 - 12/13/2009
12/13/2009 - 12/20/2009
12/20/2009 - 12/27/2009
12/27/2009 - 01/03/2010
01/03/2010 - 01/10/2010
01/10/2010 - 01/17/2010
01/17/2010 - 01/24/2010
01/24/2010 - 01/31/2010
01/31/2010 - 02/07/2010
02/07/2010 - 02/14/2010
02/14/2010 - 02/21/2010
02/21/2010 - 02/28/2010
02/28/2010 - 03/07/2010
03/07/2010 - 03/14/2010
03/14/2010 - 03/21/2010
03/21/2010 - 03/28/2010
03/28/2010 - 04/04/2010
04/04/2010 - 04/11/2010
04/11/2010 - 04/18/2010
04/18/2010 - 04/25/2010
04/25/2010 - 05/02/2010
05/02/2010 - 05/09/2010
05/09/2010 - 05/16/2010
05/16/2010 - 05/23/2010
05/23/2010 - 05/30/2010
05/30/2010 - 06/06/2010
06/06/2010 - 06/13/2010
06/13/2010 - 06/20/2010
06/20/2010 - 06/27/2010
06/27/2010 - 07/04/2010
07/04/2010 - 07/11/2010
07/11/2010 - 07/18/2010
07/18/2010 - 07/25/2010
07/25/2010 - 08/01/2010
08/01/2010 - 08/08/2010
08/08/2010 - 08/15/2010
08/15/2010 - 08/22/2010
08/22/2010 - 08/29/2010
08/29/2010 - 09/05/2010
09/05/2010 - 09/12/2010
09/12/2010 - 09/19/2010
09/19/2010 - 09/26/2010
09/26/2010 - 10/03/2010
10/03/2010 - 10/10/2010
10/10/2010 - 10/17/2010
10/17/2010 - 10/24/2010
10/24/2010 - 10/31/2010
10/31/2010 - 11/07/2010
11/07/2010 - 11/14/2010
11/14/2010 - 11/21/2010
11/21/2010 - 11/28/2010
11/28/2010 - 12/05/2010
12/05/2010 - 12/12/2010
12/12/2010 - 12/19/2010
12/19/2010 - 12/26/2010
12/26/2010 - 01/02/2011
01/02/2011 - 01/09/2011
01/09/2011 - 01/16/2011
01/16/2011 - 01/23/2011
01/23/2011 - 01/30/2011
01/30/2011 - 02/06/2011
02/06/2011 - 02/13/2011
02/13/2011 - 02/20/2011
02/20/2011 - 02/27/2011
02/27/2011 - 03/06/2011
03/06/2011 - 03/13/2011
03/13/2011 - 03/20/2011
03/20/2011 - 03/27/2011
03/27/2011 - 04/03/2011
04/03/2011 - 04/10/2011
04/10/2011 - 04/17/2011
04/17/2011 - 04/24/2011
04/24/2011 - 05/01/2011
05/01/2011 - 05/08/2011
05/08/2011 - 05/15/2011
05/15/2011 - 05/22/2011
05/22/2011 - 05/29/2011
05/29/2011 - 06/05/2011
06/05/2011 - 06/12/2011
06/12/2011 - 06/19/2011
06/19/2011 - 06/26/2011
06/26/2011 - 07/03/2011
07/03/2011 - 07/10/2011
07/10/2011 - 07/17/2011
07/17/2011 - 07/24/2011
07/24/2011 - 07/31/2011
07/31/2011 - 08/07/2011
08/07/2011 - 08/14/2011
08/14/2011 - 08/21/2011
08/21/2011 - 08/28/2011
08/28/2011 - 09/04/2011
09/04/2011 - 09/11/2011
09/11/2011 - 09/18/2011
09/18/2011 - 09/25/2011
09/25/2011 - 10/02/2011
10/02/2011 - 10/09/2011
10/09/2011 - 10/16/2011
10/16/2011 - 10/23/2011
10/23/2011 - 10/30/2011
10/30/2011 - 11/06/2011
11/06/2011 - 11/13/2011
11/13/2011 - 11/20/2011
11/20/2011 - 11/27/2011
11/27/2011 - 12/04/2011
12/04/2011 - 12/11/2011
12/11/2011 - 12/18/2011
12/18/2011 - 12/25/2011
12/25/2011 - 01/01/2012
01/01/2012 - 01/08/2012
01/08/2012 - 01/15/2012
01/15/2012 - 01/22/2012
01/22/2012 - 01/29/2012
01/29/2012 - 02/05/2012
02/05/2012 - 02/12/2012
02/12/2012 - 02/19/2012
02/19/2012 - 02/26/2012
02/26/2012 - 03/04/2012
03/04/2012 - 03/11/2012
03/11/2012 - 03/18/2012
03/18/2012 - 03/25/2012
03/25/2012 - 04/01/2012
04/01/2012 - 04/08/2012
04/08/2012 - 04/15/2012
04/15/2012 - 04/22/2012
04/22/2012 - 04/29/2012
04/29/2012 - 05/06/2012
05/06/2012 - 05/13/2012
05/13/2012 - 05/20/2012
05/20/2012 - 05/27/2012
05/27/2012 - 06/03/2012
06/03/2012 - 06/10/2012
06/10/2012 - 06/17/2012
06/17/2012 - 06/24/2012
06/24/2012 - 07/01/2012
07/01/2012 - 07/08/2012
07/08/2012 - 07/15/2012
07/15/2012 - 07/22/2012
07/22/2012 - 07/29/2012
07/29/2012 - 08/05/2012
08/05/2012 - 08/12/2012
08/12/2012 - 08/19/2012
08/19/2012 - 08/26/2012
08/26/2012 - 09/02/2012
09/02/2012 - 09/09/2012
09/09/2012 - 09/16/2012
09/16/2012 - 09/23/2012
09/23/2012 - 09/30/2012
09/30/2012 - 10/07/2012
10/07/2012 - 10/14/2012
10/14/2012 - 10/21/2012
10/21/2012 - 10/28/2012
10/28/2012 - 11/04/2012
11/04/2012 - 11/11/2012
11/11/2012 - 11/18/2012
11/18/2012 - 11/25/2012
11/25/2012 - 12/02/2012
12/02/2012 - 12/09/2012
12/09/2012 - 12/16/2012
12/16/2012 - 12/23/2012
RECENT COMMENTS
[Tip: Point cursor to any comment to see title of post being discussed.]
SEARCH THIS SITE
BLUE'S NEWS
Get the Google News widget and many other great free widgets
at Widgetbox !
ACT BLUE
BLUE LINKS
Environmental Links
Gay/Lesbian Links
News & Media Links
Organization Links
Political Links
Religious Links
Watchdog Links
BLUE ROLL
MISCELLANEOUS