Wednesday, July 18, 2007
Retreating from IraqFortunately for us, the Washington Post is still allowing Tom Ricks to commit acts of real journalism. He co-authored an article about Pentagon war-gaming over Iraq War options, Exit Strategies by Karen DeYoung and Thomas Ricks Washington Post 07/17/07, that contains this reminder:History is replete with bad withdrawal outcomes. Among the most horrific was the British departure from Afghanistan in 1842, when 16,500 active troops and civilians left Kabul thinking they had safe passage to India. Two weeks later, only one European arrived alive in Jalalabad, near the Afghan-Indian border.The risks involved in a pull-out is one argument that war supporters use to oppose any move toward withdrawal. Of course, no war critics that I can think of is pretending there are no risks to American troops in withdrawal. On the contrary, force protection concerns have bee a major piece of the various withdrawal proposals discussed in Congress. But some war critics and probably most war supporters are likely to be underestimating the possible risks of some kind of actual rout occurring, at least in some parts of Iraq under certain conditions. A badly-implented, large-scale withdrawal would be one. The aftermath of an over military attack on Iran would be another. That's not to say it's inevitable, or even the most likely scenario. But it shouldn't be discounted. And it's one of the reasons I'm dubious about the feasibility of leaving 40 or 50 thousand US troops in Iraq for training and forays against "Al Qaida". Josh Marshall adds his own comments in Getting Out, in Detail, TPM 07/17/07: The situation in a destabilized country can change very quickly once the word gets out that the occupying power is pulling out. There are some harrowing examples from the Soviet pull-out from Afghanistan, particularly cases where they literally had to fight their way out of certain areas. A key issue here is that when you figure not just how many people but how much equipment the US has in Iraq you can't just airlift everything out.Pat Lang has been warning about such risks for a while, notably in The vulnerable line of supply to US troops in Iraq Christian Science Monitor 07/21/06. Tags: iraq war, patrick lang | +Save/Share | | |
FEATURED QUOTE
No subject for immortal verse That we who lived by honest dreams Defend the bad against the worse." -- Cecil Day-Lewis from Where Are The War Poets?
ABOUT US
RECENT POSTS
ARCHIVES
RECENT COMMENTS
[Tip: Point cursor to any comment to see title of post being discussed.]
SEARCH THIS SITE
BLUE'S NEWS
ACT BLUE
BLUE LINKS
Environmental Links Gay/Lesbian Links News & Media Links Organization Links Political Links Religious Links Watchdog Links
BLUE ROLL
MISCELLANEOUS
|