Wednesday, May 24, 2006

Howling at the War on Gore by our so-called "press corps"

Bob "the Daily Howler" Somerby, who (unlike many on the right who claim to be doing "political humor"), is a professional comic. And for the most part, he's truculantly liberal.

His real contribution to political dialogue is his genuinely critical-minded analysis of the mainstream press and its treatment of major public issues. If you haven't already OD'ed on OxyContin or the FOX News Kool-Aid, and you still think there's something to the rightwingers' endlessly-repeated complain about the Liberal Press! Liberal Press! Liberal Press!, then treat yourself to a week's worth of Somerby's political commentary. You'll be amazed that you ever thought a Liberal Press existed in the United States.

Somerby has his weaknesses. He stumbled quite a bit in 2005 when he concentrated on liberal blog commentary, which doesn't quite fit into the same framework he uses when doing close readings of our "press corps". And, most surprisingly, he got hooked on the idea that the Valerie Plame outing was a minor event and its real-world political consequences were likely to be negligible.

But what Somerby says got him started writing the Howler in the first place was the appalling peformance of the mainstream press in what he calls their War on Gore in 1999-2000. He knows this subject inside-out. And now that Gore is in the news with his new movie, and speculation is rife that he will run for re-election as President in 2008, he's turning his attention to the press corps' anti-Gore "scripts" as they appear in real time.

So this is a good time to check in on the Howler. Lately he's been harshing on journalist and alleged liberal Joe Klein.


Klein is Time magazine's resident liberal, who has lately taken to specializing in pimping Republican Party talking points in the guise of giving friendly advice to Democrats.

Somerby writes in his 05/24/06 offering:

But just note — even as Klein gives back-handed praise to Gore’s work at these sessions, the tiny shiv must be sent to the chest. “Gore went on and on (and on),” Klein complains, as all in his cohort did before him, angered by the endless Q-and-A’s they were forced to stay and report on. How dare he take so many questions from so many actual voters? They longed to go home and watch King Kong; they longed to go back to the Wayfarer Inn and have seven beers with their pals—maybe eight. And yesterday, [Marueen] Dowd was angered, again, as a pol discussed a major problem. As we've long told you, these people are straight outta Marie Antoinette —and they just won't be treated this way. Their powdered wigs get all out of joint when pols make them think about problems. That's why they sit on Air Force 1 and watch Kong, skipping [the Michael] Hayden [hearings]. And that's why all pundits are calling Gore "nerd" as they opine about his new, weighty film. These are people who can't conceive of respect for actual mental attainment. Truly, they’re people who just can't imagine why we'd discuss a real problem. ...

Sadly, hapless Joe Klein is now becoming King of Press Scripts about Campaign 2000. It would be hard to find a more laughable book than his definingly awful Politics Lost — a book whose author can't argue his own basic themes for much more than a page at a time. But Klein offers simple-minded, dumb assessments of our recent White House races — and the usual suspects have appeared at the trough, eager to channel this wisdom. ...

For what it's worth, Klein may be the least coherent human being currently found on the planet. As everyone knows, he claims to be seeking an "authentic" politics, in which candidates defy their wretched consultants, speaking their real minds to the voters in inspiring "Turnip Day" moments. (Pages 23-24. A “Turnip Day” moment is a "spontaneous moment" that "gives us real insight into those who would lead us." In Turnip Day moments, a politician "shows us something of himself, something that hasn’t been pureed by pollsters.") And yet, when Klein discusses the Bush-Gore campaign, he constantly seems to praise Bush for hiding his soul — and he seems to criticize Gore for doing the opposite. ...

But why, exactly, did Candidate Gore have trouble seeming "authentic" and truthful [in the 2000 campaign]? Duh! Because these lies were typed again and again — and again, and again, and then ten times more! Klein, of course, evades this nicely, presenting a far more pleasing story—although he can’t seem to stick to his themes from one paragraph to the next. But so what? Dumb-ass pundits are typing Klein’s scripts — Dowd, and Heilemann, and Greene, and others — and many young liberals are being fooled about their lives in the process. Yes, we liberals are getting fooled once again, by a vacuous millionaire press corps—even as this inexcusable gang is scripting our next White House campaign. That next campaign—the one they’re now scripting—is going to be won by a saint.
The "saint" to whom he's referring is the great Maverick McCain. And Somerby has also been following the fawning press coverage of him lately. According the press corps' script for McCain, he's always the bold Maverick, the "straight-talking" man of integrity. Even when he's dissembling, kissing up to neo-Confederates and religious know-nothings and faithfully supporting Bush's Iraq War (except to argue that we need to escalate and level more cities like in Fallujah).

I hope Somerby stays focused for a while on political commentary and analysis. He was spending a lot of time the last few months on a detailed analysis of how to unpack reports on school quality, which never really caught my interest.

But the press corps' War on Gore - on that subject he's "incomparable" (one of his signature words).

| +Save/Share | |




FEATURED QUOTE

"It is the logic of our times
No subject for immortal verse
That we who lived by honest dreams
Defend the bad against the worse."


-- Cecil Day-Lewis from Where Are The War Poets?


ABOUT US

  • What is the Blue Voice?
  • Bruce Miller
  • Fdtate
  • Marcia Ellen (on hiatus)
  • Marigolds2
  • Neil
  • Tankwoman
  • Wonky Muse

  • RECENT POSTS

  • My Secret for Finding Great Background Material
  • Stinking Up The Hill
  • The Da Vinci Code willies
  • US-Iranian diplomacy
  • The Latest on Karl Rove
  • Have You Heard About It?
  • Much Worry About Nothing
  • The Human Warehouse Industry
  • Let's Kick It!
  • Opposing war on Iran

  • ARCHIVES




    RECENT COMMENTS

    [Tip: Point cursor to any comment to see title of post being discussed.]
    SEARCH THIS SITE
    Google
    www TBV

    BLUE'S NEWS





    ACT BLUE











    BLUE LINKS

    Environmental Links
    Gay/Lesbian Links
    News & Media Links
    Organization Links
    Political Links
    Religious Links
    Watchdog Links

    BLUE ROLL


    MISCELLANEOUS

    Atom/XML Feed
    Blogarama - Blog Directory
    Blogwise - blog directory

    Blogstreet
    Haloscan


    Blogger

    hits since 06-13-2005

    site design: wonky muse
    image: fpsoftlab.com