Wednesday, July 19, 2006

Middle East news and analysis

From Bush's "Mideast Strategy: Seek Change, Not Quick Peace" by Neil King, Jr., Karby Leggett and Jay Solomon Wall Street Journal print edition 07/19/06

Ten years ago, when Hezbollah and Israeli forces engaged in a multiweek bloodbath, President Clinton sent Secretary of State Warren Christopher to the region for six days of intensive shuttle diplomacy between Damascus and Jerusalem. In the end, he won a cease-fire deal that ended the fighting, at least temporarily.

Today, the Bush administration has a starkly different approach. Emphasizing fundamental change over short-term peace and stability. President Bush and his top diplomat, Secretary of State Condoleezza Rice, have no intention of launching a similar round of diplomacy to end the current fighting. Visiting Damascus is out of the question. And a cease-fire isn't their most pressing aim, they say.
Has Bush Gone Multilateral? by Ivo Daalder TPM Cafe 07/11/06:

While there has been a shift in foreign policy during Bush's second term ... , it’s not so much a shift from unilateralism to multilateralism as it is a shift from relying on the use of force to doing nothing.

The big change in the second term is that Bush has abandoned one of the defining characteristics of his first term foreign policy: the reliance on unilateral force as a means to change a regime’s policies, if not the actual regime itself. It was this combination of unilateralism, preemptive force, and regime change that made Bush’s foreign policy revolutionary. Abandon the idea of preemptive force, and you’re left with nothing more than hoping for change. And hope, as Colin Powell was wont to say, is not much of a strategy.

Instead of force, Bush and Co. now emphasize the importance of "diplomacy" — whence the belief of many that the administration has embraced multilateralism almost to a fault. But what the administration is doing isn’t diplomacy — defined by the great British diplomat and historian, Harold Nicholson, "as the art of negotiating documents in a ratifiable and therefore dependable form." Rather, what Bush is doing is just talk (or talking about talk). But diplomacy "is by no means the art of conversation," Nicolson noted. "Diplomacy, if it is ever to be effective, should be a disagreeable business. And one recorded in hard print."

Bush isn’t about to get into such disagreeable business.
So Bush stuffs his face and cusses at Tony Blair with his mouth full and feels up the German Chancellor while another part of the Middle East blows up.

Meanwhile, back in Iraq ...


That "good news" we keep hearing about so far hasn't been good enough to win the counterinsurgency war or stop the civil war.

Oh, and Turkey may invade: Turkey risks US anger over plan to attack Kurds by Louis Meixler Independent 07/19/06.

The Turkish army may move into northern Iraq if violence by Turkish-Kurdish guerrillas continues, officials said yesterday.

Such a move could put Turkey on a collision course with the United States, which has repeatedly warned against unilateral action in Iraq. ...

Any operation is unlikely to take place before the end of August, when the current military chief of staff will be replaced by an officer widely regarded as a hardliner.

The plans range from limited artillery and air strikes on guerrilla bases to attacks by commando forces or a broader ground offensive. (my emphasis)
Yes, the article says that "the United States .. has repeatedly warned against unilateral action in Iraq". We have some experience now in the consequences of such a move. No, I forgot: we have a "coalition". And, plus, the Iraqi army and police are "standing up" by the tens of thousands.

For more on the Israel-Hizbollah-Lebanon situation, see also:

Bush's vision, and the region, appear to be near collapse by Marc Sandalow San Francisco Chronicle 07/19/06:

The oft-stated hope that a new Iraqi government would swiftly transform the region's fractured politics has been realized with unintended consequences: an emboldened Iran; the victory of Hamas in Palestinian elections; and Syria's departure from Lebanon. The familiar strain has been hatred between the Arabs and Israelis and a widely held assumption that the situation will grow worse before it improves.

"Unless and until you solve the Arab-Israel conflict, you are going to have instability in the region," said Steven Cook, a fellow at the Council on Foreign Relations in New York.
From Israel's tight window for action by Joshua Mitnick Christian Science Monitor 07/20/06:

With tacit support from the US, Israel has operated with a relatively free hand, leaving hundreds of Lebanese civilians dead. But that window of opportunity will close as the US ramps up cease-fire efforts and as images of ruin in Lebanon begin to dominate the international agenda.

"The clock is ticking, and the objective is to weaken Hizbullah to the greatest extent possible," says Yossi Alpher, the editor of the online Middle East affairs journal Bitterlemons.org.

"When the images on television of the bombing of Beirut, of Lebanese victims of destruction, and of infrastructure reaches a point where it pressures the US, [British Prime Minister] Tony Blair, and European leaders, then the process of winding down will begin. The pressure is starting now," he says.

As Israeli Foreign Minister Tzipi Livni held talks with European envoy Javier Solana, US Secretary of State Condoleezza Rice is poised to visit the region in the next week. Israeli observers speculate that gives the military only a matter of several more days to operate.
From In Iraq, Civil War All but Declared: Officials see the latest killings - 130 lives in two days - as a slide into a full-scale conflict by Borzou Daragahi Los Angeles Times 07/19/06

Many members of Iraq's political class spoke gravely of the massacres and bombings of the last few days, even as two U.S. Cabinet officials visiting Baghdad's heavily fortified Green Zone this week touted Iraq as a potential bonanza for private investors.

The Iraqi Islamic Party, the largest Sunni Arab political group, warned Tuesday that "Iraq is witnessing a grave escalation in violence," and it called on Iraqis "to return to their senses instead of slipping into the abyss."

The surge in violence has terrified residents of Baghdad and other mixed Sunni and Shiite areas. The Baghdad airport has been flooded with Iraqis of modest means seeking to escape even temporarily the country's upswing in sectarian slayings. ...

Even those who hesitate to call Iraq's sectarian violence a civil war have begun saying that defusing the situation will require the international mechanisms used to mediate previous ethnic, religious and political conflicts in Central America, the former Yugoslavia and Sri Lanka.

"I start to feel the need to say that there is a civil war," said Salim Abdullah Jabouri, a Sunni politician, "in order to borrow the tools and solutions of past civil wars to apply them here, and to call upon the international community to deal with Iraq's problems on this basis."
And, just to remember the good ole days, Cakewalk In Iraq by Ken Adelman 02/13/02:

I believe demolishing Hussein's military power and liberating Iraq would be a cakewalk. Let me give simple, responsible reasons: (1) It was a cakewalk last time; (2) they've become much weaker; (3) we've become much stronger; and (4) now we're playing for keeps.
Ah, yes, the brave "Churchillian" rhetoric that got us into the Iraq War. Those were the heroic days, when great prophets walked the pages of the Washington Post.

Here's how the cakewalk is going: Iraqi suicide bomber lures workers with job offer, kills 59 Daily Star 07/19/06

For more on Israel/Lebanon/Palestine:

Israeli jets hit central Beirut Aljazeera 07/19/06

From IDF: We need two weeks to end Lebanon operation by Amos Harel and Avi Issacharoff Ha'aretz 07/19/06

Defense Minister Amir Peretz said on Tuesday, during a meeting with senior IDF officers, that attacks against Hezbollah would continue "without letup and time limit."

A senior military source said on Tuesday that Israel seeks "to significantly weaken Hezbollah but not crush it." He said that "it is impossible to crush a popular, religious movement."

The source added that had the government of Israel reacted differently to the abduction of three soldiers in an attack on Har Dov in October 2000 and behaved as Israel is doing now, it is likely that the attack last Wednesday could have been prevented.
From How good it feels to be just by Gideon Samet Ha'aretz 07/19/06:

The virtue of the war in the North, against a relatively small and weak enemy, is that all the fire and smoke will be ended with an agreement. But the achievement in Lebanon is liable to provide a basis for the illusion that our might could well lead to an agreement with the Palestinians as well. There, the Israel Air Force and the smart bombs - or so they seem - will never suffice. There, instead of getting drunk on being just (to its mind), Israel will have to be, for a change, smart and broad-minded as well.
From 'Intensive fighting will continue' by Herb Keinon Jerusalem Post 07/19/06

The security cabinet met Wednesday morning and issued a statement afterward that "the intensive fighting against Hizbullah will continue, including attacks on Hizbullah infrastructure and command posts, its operational abilities, its armaments, and the leadership of the organization."

The statement reiterated that the goals of the operation were to return the kidnapped soldiers, to stop the rocket attacks on Israeli communities, and to "remove the threat."

Regarding the possible diplomatic solutions to the crisis, the security cabinet set three conditions: the unconditional return of the captured soldiers, an end to the rocket fire on Israel, and the complete implementation of UN Security Council Resolution 1559, which includes the complete dismantling of the armed militia in Lebanon, the extension of Lebanese sovereignty throughout the country, and deployment of the Lebanese army along the border with Israel.
Red Cross: 'serious questions' over Israel's assault on Lebanon Daily Star/AFP 07/19/06

Our coarse president can't fix the Middle East by Joe Conason New York Observer/WorkingforChange.com 07/19/06 reminds us not to underestimate the incompetence factor in historical events:

Watching the President of the United States try to fulfill his responsibilities at an international summit is a sobering experience these days. To observe George W. Bush talking trash, chewing with his mouth open and demonstrating his ignorance of geography marks still another step down in the continuing decline of U.S. prestige. It's the diplomatic equivalent of flag burning.

While Mr. Bush's little misadventures make headlines, what they symbolize is a collapse of policy and a vacuum of competence that are far more troubling than mere cloddishness. Preoccupied from the beginning of his presidency with Iraq, alienated from our traditional allies and the United Nations and neglectful of broader American interests in the Middle East, he and his team now confront a sudden crisis for which they seem woefully unprepared. ...

Recall that when the Bush administration decided to invade Iraq-on the pretext of disarming Saddam Hussein-a new era of peace and democracy was supposed to dawn. Making an example of the toppled Saddam would, according to neoconservative theory, persuade other despots in the region to reform and reconcile themselves to co-existence with Israel, and stimulate the “peace process” too. (That same theory, of course, similarly predicted flower-strewn parades in Baghdad and enough oil revenues to finance the whole bloody enterprise.)

Indeed, when the weapons of mass destruction didn't turn up, those anticipated dividends became the retrospective justification for the war. ...

Their marvelous theory lies in gory ruins, but the neoconservatives are again banging the drums with as much gusto as if they had been vindicated. The missile barrages between Israel and Lebanon are actually the harbinger of World War III, they burble, and frankly they can't wait for World War IV. Things haven't worked out in Iraq, but why not take this opportunity to hit Iran and Syria?

Let us hope that Mr. Bush resists this mad counsel. While his performance so far has been dismal, especially in his reluctance to endorse an immediate ceasefire, at least he isn't promoting a wider war. Yet while he dithers, the killing and destruction continue-which is exactly what Hezbollah and Hamas want.
From What was revealed by that open mike by Robert Scheer San Francisco Chronicle 07/19/06

What is truly "ironic," however, is that the Bush administration, having overstretched our military and generated no foreign policy ideas beyond the willy-nilly "projection" of military force, has become a helpless bystander as the entire region threatens to burn.

Responding to Bush, Blair at least sounded somewhat constructive, offering to go directly to the Mideast and pave the way for a visit by U.S. Secretary of State Condoleezza Rice. In this, he seemed to be unwittingly aligned with former Secretary of State Madeleine Albright, who expressed on Sunday frustration with her successor for not leaving the conference to engage in emergency shuttle diplomacy in the Mideast.

Where Albright was critical of the "disaster" in Iraq for distracting from the dormant Mideast peace process, Rice was shrilly defensive.

"For the last 60 years, American administrations of both stripe - Democrat, Republican - traded what they thought was security and stability and turned a blind eye to the absence of democratic forces, to the absence of pluralism in the region," she said Sunday. "That policy has changed."


| +Save/Share | |




FEATURED QUOTE

"It is the logic of our times
No subject for immortal verse
That we who lived by honest dreams
Defend the bad against the worse."


-- Cecil Day-Lewis from Where Are The War Poets?


ABOUT US

  • What is the Blue Voice?
  • Bruce Miller
  • Fdtate
  • Marcia Ellen (on hiatus)
  • Marigolds2
  • Neil
  • Tankwoman
  • Wonky Muse

  • RECENT POSTS

  • Juan Cole on the Israeli-Lebanese war
  • Good News
  • The Price of Freedom
  • HR 810 Passes in the Senate, Presidential Veto Pro...
  • Dobson's World: Enlightenment is bad, embrace the ...
  • You can't make stuff like this up
  • Helping Miracles to Happen
  • A Cease-Fire Will Help
  • Repairing Humpty Dumpty in the Middle East
  • Squaring the circle of idealism and pragmatism in ...

  • ARCHIVES




    RECENT COMMENTS

    [Tip: Point cursor to any comment to see title of post being discussed.]
    SEARCH THIS SITE
    Google
    www TBV

    BLUE'S NEWS





    ACT BLUE











    BLUE LINKS

    Environmental Links
    Gay/Lesbian Links
    News & Media Links
    Organization Links
    Political Links
    Religious Links
    Watchdog Links

    BLUE ROLL


    MISCELLANEOUS

    Atom/XML Feed
    Blogarama - Blog Directory
    Blogwise - blog directory

    Blogstreet
    Haloscan


    Blogger

    hits since 06-13-2005

    site design: wonky muse
    image: fpsoftlab.com